What is it? It's heat, you know, warm temperatures. There are several possible ways of applying it to your body that basically break down into local application (wheat bags, hot water bottles, heat pads, Deep Heat, Tiger Balm - actually, technically the latter two just feel hot, but they have a similar effect on your body) and systemic application (saunas, steam rooms, heat lamps, sunny weather).
Does it work? As a temporary (partial) relief, yes. As a permanent fix, not so much. My experience is that when I'm having a bad day, especially if the problem is in my hips or my upper back, then a microwaved wheat bag applied to the sore area can reduce the level of pain I'm in or even, if I'm really lucky, temporarily completely fix the pain. It certainly makes sitting more comfortable. My favourite wheat bag is one like this for the upper back and shoulders, but I find its shape also makes it practical for the neck or hips or anywhere else I want to put it, and its large size means it retains heat slightly longer. I also own this electric back and neck heat pad with Velcro straps that covers the whole of my back and which is intended to be worn, but because of the fact it plugs into the mains I often just attach to the back of my office chair rather than my actual back. This is excellent for when I'm sitting in the office and want a longer lasting heat and, providing the instructions don't specify that you mustn't, you can also take it to bed and go to sleep on it (mine turns itself off after 90 minutes). However, it is less good than a wheat bag for pain in places other than my back. On top of that, I also own this massager with heat, although I find I don't use that so much, as the massager bits means it's not really comfortable enough to leave on my office chair all winter like I do with the heat pad. On the other hand, if our car's electrics worked properly and I could plug it into the car as is intended, I think it might be beneficial for long journeys. I don't find either Tiger Balm or Deep Heat as effective as a wheat bag, but I get the impression both provide me with some pain relief.
I also sometimes go and use my gym's sauna or steam room when I've got a lot of muscle pain and some spare time, and I've also been under a physio's heat lamp. Speaking as someone for whom heat works fairly well, I consider the wheat bag an indispensable part of my armoury, but the sauna and steam room is more of a pleasant extra that I have thrown in anyway with my gym membership. I'm not convinced that I'd actually pay extra money for the level of benefits it brings. I don't get the impression it has any real lasting effect, but I do often feel a bit better while in there and it is one of the more pleasant ways to spend time when I'm in too much pain to do much else. As for the heat lamp, I hated that with a passion. To use it I had to lie on a physio's table for about 30 minutes and then travel home in the -17° C temperatures Frankfurt was torturing me with that February. At that point, even lying down increased my pain, so as far as I can make out, this did not help me at all. It's certainly not something I would want to pay money for.
Who does it work for? This is another one for people with musculoskeletal pain, as one of the modes by which it works is probably by encouraging your muscles to relax. In particular, it may be good for hand, foot and joint pain, as they are less able to regulate their own temperature irrespective of any heat or cold you have applied to them (or for people with a hypermobility syndrome, as we in any case tend to regulate our temperature poorly and have a tendency towards Raynaud's phenomenon). If you have neuropathic pain and already own a wheat bag or a hot water bottle anyway, it might be worth giving it a try, as I think it may also work by distracting you from the pain (i.e. your central nervous system finds it hard to focus on the signals its receiving both from your pain and the heat at once and if you're lucky stops noticing the pain and only or mainly notices the heat). I'm not sure enough that this would work to recommend buying any equipment, but if you have it or can borrow it anyway, why not give it a shot and see if it has any impact?
Who doesn't it work for? Do NOT use this on inflammation (obvious trauma with redness and swelling) as this will make inflammation worse. However, according to Paul Ingraham, whose website I find very well researched and thoughtful, chronic pain is very rarely caused by inflammation, even when it's in your muscles, it's more likely to be muscle knots than inflammation. So bottom line: if you have a swollen, new injury, don't use heat on it, but you're likely to be pretty safe with chronic pain. This article suggests erring on the side of heat instead of ice for chronic pain. Also, I notice from my own experience that my experiences of cold have mainly been bad (I feel worse in winter) and that I look forward to heat in advance (all apart from that dreadful heat lamp where I had to lie in an uncomfortable position). Basically, as these things mainly work while you're doing them, with maybe a temporary after-effect, if you're applying a temperature that makes you feel worse, stop doing it immediately!
Where can I get it? You can get wheat bags, heat pads and water bottles online or from shops such as Argos. You'll sometimes also find wheat bags on market stalls. Deep Heat and Tiger Balm are available online, from pharmacies and from larger supermarkets. Most gyms have saunas and steam rooms and you may also find them at spas or hotels. You can buy your own heat lamp or you may be able to get treatment at a physiotherapist or similar therapist (my treatment with a heat lamp was in Germany, and I've never heard a single physio or osteopath mention one in the UK). I can't recommend heat lamps from my personal experience.
How much does it cost? You can get a standard wheat bag for as little as £5.18 or a neck, shoulders and back one like mine for £14.90. Don't forget, you also need a microwave to use them plus the cost of the electricity to microwave them. Alternatively a hot water bottle can cost as little as £2.38 plus the electricity to heat the kettle. If it's possible for you, I strongly recommend a wheat bag over a hot water bottle because they mould better to your body. My electric heat pad for my whole back costs £31.99. Ones for smaller areas, such as the lower back, may be cheaper, such as this one for £19.99. I recommend against click heat pads such as this one because you need to heat them in water in a pan not the microwave to restore them and I also found that I had frequently left a tiny crystal in it, so when I came to use it, the whole thing had recrystallised and needed to be heated again. These are more for places where you don't have access to a microwave, for instance camping. If you don't have access to a microwave and if you don't mind the constant reheating in a pan, this may be a better option for you than a water bottle, but I'm not really sure the extra mouldability outweighs the difficulty of having to heat it in a pan between uses.
Saunas and steam rooms are generally available as part of gym membership. Other than that, spas sometimes offer access to steam rooms or saunas, such as in this £19 package (don't do the cold parts, you'll reverse any the good you just did by making your muscles tense up, also if you then go back out into cold weather my experience suggests you may also reverse all the good you've done, so I'm not convinced these things are worth a special trip for in winter). If you already have an electric blanket, that can also help, although I wouldn't recommend it as a first choice of products to buy for heat treatment.
Is there a cheap or free version? The free version is to dress warmly and/or sit under a blanket (which is better than not doing anything, but not nearly as good as a hot water bottle or wheat bag). Alternatively, go and sit outside when it's warm and sunny. The next cheapest version is a hot water bottle for £2.38 (although if money is a real problem, don't forget to factor in the cost of boiling the kettle). To my mind, if you have or can get a microwave, the wheat bag is the most cost-effective choice (by the way, it really doesn't matter if it still smells of lavender or not for your heat treatment, and if you're not too fussed whether it still has a lavender smell, a wheat bag will last for years and years). You may also be able to save a small amount of money by making your own wheat bag, for instance of rice.
Is there any evidence for it? It's not really been the subject of many trials, but what evidence there is is at least mildly positive. This randomised controlled trial showed that one form of heat treatment, in this case infrared therapy, was more effective than placebo in reducing pain in people with chronic low back pain. Unfortunately, because they only tested infrared treatment, you can't be certain this result also applies to other forms of heat treatment. The only other trial I found for heat and chronic pain is still in the phase of recruiting patients. It will specifically look at heating/cooling therapy for people with chronic low back pain. A 2010 randomised controlled trial showed ice and heat packs were both a little bit beneficial on neck and back pain in people with acute pain in a hospital, another randomised controlled trial found the inclusion of a heat wrap in treating acute low back pain helpful, and this one found continuous low level heat wrap therapy helpful in the prevention or early phase treatment of pain after exercise. None of this is as useful as evidence that shows benefits of treatment using heat for chronic pain specifically, but it is enough to suggest that heat is worth considering as a treatment for pain, especially if it doesn't cost you much to try it.
Are there any downsides? If you're silly about it you could scald yourself, so don't pour boiling water all over yourself when filling a hot water bottle, and if your wheat bag or hot water bottle feels too hot, take it off your skin until it's cooled down or wrap it in towels or jumpers until it doesn't feel too hot or until it cools down. If an electric device feels too hot it's probably broken, so throw it out or get it repaired. Don't heat your wheat bag so ridiculously hot that you risk starting a fire either. Don't sit in the sun so long that you get sun burnt or heat stroke and don't stay in a sauna or steam room for longer than recommended (or go in one at all if there are medical reasons why you shouldn't). In addition, if you don't have the capacity to tell if something is hazardously hot for any reason, always get someone else to test your device to see if it is too hot to sensibly use before using it, or you could hurt yourself or accidentally burn your house down. Basically, don't stop doing all the sensible things you normally do to not get burnt or heat stroke or heat exhaustion or dehydration just because you're using heat for medicinal purposes.
Also, this is probably just a temporary masking method that doesn't heal the root cause. But then again, if there were non-temporary fixes for our chronic pain that healed the root cause we wouldn't have chronic pain in the first place, so let's not dismiss cheap, temporary masking methods too quickly.
One final thought for women, if overheating tends to give you thrush, you'll probably want to be careful with where you use the heat source and not overheat your body as a whole.
Are there any other upsides? This is drug-free, cheap method of reducing pain. Also, it's lovely to be warm.
Was it worth the money? Definitely, particularly the wheat bag (although I wouldn't do the heat lamp again unless you paid me).
Do you have any experiences of using heat to treat pain? What does it work for? What was a pointless waste of time? What heat source would you recommend using or steering well clear of?